Skip to content

Fair Work Commission Ruling in Dr. Mark Colson v Barwon Health: A Crucial Precedent for Employee Rights

In a landmark case of Dr. Mark Colson v Barwon Health – Geelong Hospital, the decision set a precedent for employee rights, emphasizing the importance of clear communication and conduct guidelines within workplaces. This case serves as a key example for employees facing potentially unfair dismissal, demonstrating the role of the Fair Work Commission (FWC) in ensuring fairness and justice.

Dr. Mark Colson, an anesthetist, was dismissed from Barwon Health on 30 May 2012, under charges of serious misconduct. Arguing that his termination was unjust, Dr. Colson lodged an unfair dismissal application with the FWC. Commissioner Roe ruled in favor of Dr. Colson, stating the proven misconduct didn’t rise to the level of serious misconduct, thereby justifying reinstatement.

The grounds for dismissal, according to Barwon Health, were two-fold. Firstly, Dr. Colson was accused of willingly breaching Barwon Health’s billing guidelines and directives. Secondly, he was alleged to have published an offensive letter intended to challenge the authority of management and tarnish Barwon Health’s reputation.

However, the FWC Commissioner found that the first allegation could not be substantiated. The guidelines and directives didn’t explicitly exclude the billing methodology employed by Dr. Colson. Furthermore, there was no concrete evidence of Dr. Colson’s persistent refusal to comply with policies or directives.

While the second allegation was partly substantiated, Dr. Colson’s history of similar communication styles with management and the lack of previous action by Barwon Health were taken into consideration. The FWC concluded that Barwon Health had tacitly tolerated Dr. Colson’s inappropriate communication style and had not given him explicit warnings.

The FWC noted that dismissing Dr. Colson without clearly warning him that his communication style was no longer acceptable was harsh and unreasonable. This fact, combined with his extensive clinical expertise and the impact of the dismissal on his reputation and ability to find employment, contributed to the ruling that his termination was disproportionate.

However, the FWC decided against ordering Barwon Health to pay Dr. Colson the amount of remuneration lost due to his dismissal, which exceeded $236,000. This decision was based on Dr. Colson’s proven misconduct and to stress the seriousness of his actions.

This case serves as a vital lesson for employees. It emphasizes the role of the Fair Work Commission in mediating workplace disputes and ensuring fairness. Moreover, it highlights the importance of clearly defined workplace conduct guidelines and their role in protecting employee rights.

Call Frontline Employment Defenders Now so we can help you 1300 089 353 or visit

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *